Top picks
10 models
SUV
2015–2019 Subaru Outback
$19,800
expect to pay
All-wheel-drive wagon with class-leading safety and proven reliability.
Wagon
2019–2024 Volvo V60 Cross Country
$28,500
expect to pay
Raised AWD wagon blending Volvo's safety pedigree with cargo-hauling versatility.
SUV
2020–2024 Subaru Outback
$24,500
expect to pay
Versatile AWD wagon with class-leading safety and a refined ride.
Minivan
2021–2024 Toyota Sienna
$38,000
expect to pay
Hybrid-only minivan with class-leading economy and room for the whole family.
SUV
2023–2024 Honda CR-V
$28,500
expect to pay
CR-V with hybrid-grade efficiency and top safety ratings.
SUV
2013–2018 Toyota RAV4
$17,500
expect to pay
Dependable compact SUV with top safety marks and proven reliability.
Minivan
2018–2024 Honda Odyssey
$30,200
expect to pay
Refined, reliable family hauler with confident handling and a quiet cabin.
Sedan
2018–2024 Toyota Camry
$27,300
expect to pay
Camry with top-tier reliability and the latest safety suite as standard.
Sedan
2023–2024 Honda Accord
$24,100
expect to pay
Accord pairing near-luxury comfort with rock-solid dependability.
Compact
2020–2025 Toyota Corolla
$22,500
expect to pay
Nearly-new Corolla with the latest safety suite and outstanding economy.
Second choice
20 models
Compact
2019–2024 Mazda Mazda3
$21,000
expect to pay
Mazda3 with a premium cabin and confident, fun-to-drive handling.
Compact
2014–2019 Toyota Corolla
$13,900
expect to pay
Dependable compact with low running costs and top reliability scores.
Compact
2016–2021 Honda Civic
$15,200
expect to pay
Reliable commuter with excellent fuel economy and strong safety ratings.
SUV
2017–2022 Honda CR-V
$20,500
expect to pay
Roomy compact SUV with class-leading cargo space and a proven powertrain.
Truck
2016–2023 Toyota Tacoma
$32,000
expect to pay
Recent-vintage Tacoma pairing legendary reliability with modern tow tech.
Hatchback
2019–2024 Toyota Corolla Hatchback
$20,500
expect to pay
Cargo-friendly Corolla with hatchback practicality and standout fuel economy.
Wagon
2018–2020 Buick Regal TourX
$16,400
expect to pay
Underrated AWD wagon with European road manners and roomy cargo space.
Hatchback
2019–2024 Mazda Mazda3 Hatchback
$17,900
expect to pay
Stylish, fun-to-drive hatchback with a near-luxury cabin for the price.
SUV
2017–2024 Mazda CX-5
$16,800
expect to pay
Stylish crossover with a quiet cabin and above-average reliability scores.
Truck
2017–2024 Honda Ridgeline
$24,600
expect to pay
Car-like ride in a midsize truck with AWD and verified maintenance.
Truck
2016–2023 Toyota Tacoma
$27,500
expect to pay
Legendary-reliability midsize truck with 4WD and strong resale value.
Compact
2014–2018 Mazda Mazda3
$14,500
expect to pay
Sharp-handling compact with upscale interior and strong long-term reliability.
Compact
2017–2020 Hyundai Elantra
$11,500
expect to pay
Value-packed sedan with a long warranty tail and frugal running costs.
Truck
2015–2022 Chevrolet Colorado
$21,500
expect to pay
Capable midsize truck with a tidy footprint and reasonable maintenance costs.
Hatchback
2009–2013 Honda Fit
$8,200
expect to pay
Clever, ultra-reliable hatchback with a magic-folding back seat and standout cargo space.
Compact
2012–2015 Honda Civic
$7,600
expect to pay
Dependable commuter with excellent fuel economy and proven long-term reliability.
Compact
2014–2016 Toyota Corolla
$8,900
expect to pay
Bulletproof compact that runs forever on a budget, with frugal running costs.
Truck
2007–2021 Toyota Tundra
$29,500
expect to pay
Full-size truck with a reputation for going the distance and holding value.
Hatchback
2012–2014 Kia Soul
$7,400
expect to pay
Roomy, boxy hatchback with a tall cabin and easy cargo loading for the price.
Compact
2012–2014 Toyota Yaris
$6,800
expect to pay
No-frills subcompact that sips fuel and keeps maintenance costs low year after year.
What you're looking for
Tell us your priorities — we'll suggest models worth focusing on.
Fuel Efficiency
Drive
Comfort
Seats
Price level
Age